Uncommon Sense

December 30, 2017

The Only Way to Less Inequality?

Here is a devastating assessment of the actual cost of the GOP’s recent tax bill. It is by Bill Honig, who I have met and consider to be a smart and honorable man.


Much of the GOP tax bill has been labeled as “bad news,” so I do not think you will be surprised to find out the news is worse that we thought. I bring this up because a new book has come out that addresses the history of inequality and the only forces that seem to reverse it for even small periods of time. The book is “The Great Leveler” by Walter Scheidel. Here is part of the description of that book (from Amazon.com):

How only violence and catastrophes have consistently reduced inequality throughout world history
Are mass violence and catastrophes the only forces that can seriously decrease economic inequality? To judge by thousands of years of history, the answer is yes. Tracing the global history of inequality from the Stone Age to today, Walter Scheidel shows that inequality never dies peacefully. Inequality declines when carnage and disaster strike and increases when peace and stability return. The Great Leveler is the first book to chart the crucial role of violent shocks in reducing inequality over the full sweep of human history around the world.

Ever since humans began to farm, herd livestock, and pass on their assets to future generations, economic inequality has been a defining feature of civilization. Over thousands of years, only violent events have significantly lessened inequality. The “Four Horsemen” of leveling—mass-mobilization warfare, transformative revolutions, state collapse, and catastrophic plagues—have repeatedly destroyed the fortunes of the rich. Scheidel identifies and examines these processes, from the crises of the earliest civilizations to the cataclysmic world wars and communist revolutions of the twentieth century. Today, the violence that reduced inequality in the past seems to have diminished, and that is a good thing. But it casts serious doubt on the prospects for a more equal future.

This book supports my view that the fundamental purpose of civilization is to create inequality of income, wealth, and opportunity, for the benefit of the elites, both secular and religious, with the costs to be born by everyone else. And I have advocated, sometimes tongue in cheek, that it was time to get out the pitchforks and torches, but if this author is correct only “mass-mobilization warfare, transformative revolutions, state collapse, and catastrophic plagues—have repeatedly destroyed the fortunes of the rich” we are in quite dire straights. We have been making war on other countries for over 200 years of our existence, and it is a very rare occasion for war to intrude on our shores, and a “mass mobilization” for war means the war has to be very, very large indeed. That is a path, in this age of nuclear weapons, I do not wish to take. State collapse and catastrophic plagues aren’t appealing, so that leaves “transformative revolutions” to us. Such revolutions can be non-violent (rare) or violent and considering the polarization of the U.S. and our massive personal stockpiles of weaponry, it looks like a peaceful revolution will be a very good trick to pull off, indeed.

I do note, however, that the only way to avoid the toxic effects of wealth is to make sure great amounts of it either do not occur or are reduced when they occur. This means that a major function of a democracy is to … wait for it … wait … redistribute wealth away from the wealthy. Unfortunately, our governments have been captured by the wealthy who have been busy redistributing wealth to the wealthy for the past 40 years.

My only hope to avoid large scale violence is that the GOP’s paymasters will so overplay their hand that there will be a quasi-socialist revolution that will give power back to the people and defang the wealthy elites now running the show. My preference is for new political parties (two at least) as the ones we have have failed miserably and have too much baggage to carry into the future.


  1. Odd how we happen upon the same themes, separated only by weeks or months. I too feel that only collapse can cure inequality. My personal favorite is the CME (or two of them, the second right behind the first), like we just missed in July 2012. Toast the grid and the aristocrats will starve too.


    Comment by Anony Mole — December 30, 2017 @ 3:33 pm | Reply

  2. I do not wish to see a violent revolt. My reason is that nothing much really good comes from violence. The nasty thing is, I don’t see any way for a non-violent revolt to have any hope in hell of working out for the working class/poor people. Yes, I despise the greed of the very rich. I have said here before that I see their greed as having no limits at all. I know I have said that I am certain that IF they ever owned the entire solar system, they would still want more. That type greed is what I despise. I fear it will take a very violent revolt to change things. The really nasty bit is that many innocent people will be killed or seriously maimed then. Yeah, OK I AM a nasty, bad attitude old SOB who is very sarcastic and cynical, I do however have a deep caring feel for my fellow humans and all life in general. Less than half way through my tour in the damn fool Vietnam war, I decided I’d never resort to physical violence unless it was to defend my loved ones/close friends from serious harm. My violence is now verbal. And man, I can cuss up a bloody cat 7 hurricane when need be. Yeah, I know, the current hurricane scale only goes to a cat 5. Well, you never have heard this old SOB get angry. It ain’t pretty.


    Comment by Walter Kronkat — December 30, 2017 @ 5:09 pm | Reply

    • Wait a minute … *we won’t like you if you get angry*? Hey, you aren’t the Incredible Hulk are you? If you are, there are a couple of buildings in Washington, D.C. I want you to demolish, but only when they are fully occupied. (Violence but minimal violence.)

      On Sat, Dec 30, 2017 at 5:09 PM, Class Warfare Blog wrote:



      Comment by Steve Ruis — December 30, 2017 @ 8:49 pm | Reply

  3. “You say you want a revolution, well well you know….”.
    As long as the country’s military is in firm control of the powers that be. There will never be a successful violent revolution. Look at the French Revolutions. The failed Revolutions of 1848. Only when the 82d Airborne, 10th Mountain, 2d Armored, Marines etc say “hell no we won’t go” and mean it will a revolution of that sort work. Unless things have changed radically from my 20 years in the infantry, that isn’t going to happen. Now another possible course would be a dedicated revolutionary movement with high powered sniper weapons and begin to cull the herd. Sort of like the Anarchist movements of the late 1800’s. Don’t see that happening either. So that leaves a meteor strike, alien invasion, mega volcano or plague. Sometimes in my more dispairing moments, like Walter I find myself saying “come on asteroid!”


    Comment by Holding The Line In Florida — January 1, 2018 @ 11:35 am | Reply

    • I remember when this country mobilized the military, okay the National Guard, against citizens. It did not go well. If this were done correctly, the military would come over to our side and that would end that. As I have said often enough regarding gun buyers/militia members looking to oppose the tyranny of the federal government “Good luck with that when the Fifth Cavalry comes a callin’ in tanks and helicopters, and suppressing fire. If we were to launch a rebellion, we would be snuffed out like a candle. We need a revolution, not a rebellion.

      Liked by 1 person

      Comment by Steve Ruis — January 1, 2018 @ 2:36 pm | Reply

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Blog at WordPress.com.

%d bloggers like this: