Class Warfare Blog

March 6, 2011

Even More Republican Perfidy

Filed under: Economics,Politics — Steve Ruis @ 9:14 am
Tags: , , ,

Two articles in the business section of my morning paper showed patterns that give the lie to many Republican policies. One showed that a highly touted business stimulation plan of the state of Illinois was less than sterling. Over half of the businesses initially qualifying for the plan either didn’t qualify thereafter or didn’t need the money. The other indicated that two out of three businesses paid no Illinois state tax last year.

Each of these have exact parallels nationally. Two of three business paid no business tax nationally also, and many if not most of the “business stimulation” programs are quite unneeded. But Republicans are claiming that businesses need incentives to hire more workers. They claim businesses need tax incentives and reductions in regulations. For example, in Wisconsin, the Republican majority provided $140 million dollars in unneeded business tax breaks before screaming “there’s a huge state government economic crisis and we have to break the unions to solve it.” Apparently they didn’t see the shortfall when they passed the giveaway of tax receipts just a month earlier.

I think it can be safely argued that there are bad regulations on the books, but nobody seems to be trying to root them out. Republican efforts are meat axe efforts to reduce regulation: gut the EPA, for example. Do away with the good regulations and the bad all in one stroke. Saves time, apparently. Their efforts to break unions have nothing to do with deregulating business and everything to do with eliminating opposition to anything businesses wish to do, and it seems the other things they are doing are likewise directed.

For a time, Republicans were claiming businesses weren’t hiring because capital was unavailable to them (the Federal government was borrowing all of the available capital!). This bogus claim disappeared after it was revealed that American businesses were sitting on over $2,000,000,000,000 of cash. Now that it has been revealed that two out of three businesses pay no business taxes, maybe Republicans will stop beating the “cut corporate taxes” drum, but I wouldn’t count on it.

So, why are businesses not hiring more workers, expanding operations, etc? The answer is simple: what they are missing is customers. With millions of people unemployed, still more millions losing their houses in repossessions, and countless more millions fearful of losing their jobs or having their salaries and/or number of work days reduced, people are not buying what they used to. The same is true worldwide as the recession was global, not just confined to our borders.

When this occurs, the only way that history (not just some hypothetical claim) shows that the cycle can be broken and economic growth jump started is for the government to step in and be the customer of first choice. Government has to buy things which it needs to provide the jobs, which provides the commerce that gets things going again. The prime example is infrastructure spending. If you are someone who thinks that the private sector will take care of things, think again. How many of our roads and highways were built by private means? Very, very few. How about bridges and airports? Very, very few. Building infrastructure that we all can use is a proper role of government. But detractors say, the deficit is too high! We can’t borrow money to do these projects! This is strange argument, because money is always borrowed to do these projects. And consider this: if these infrastructure problems are put on a back burner, they don’t just go away. In fact, the problems get worse over time and get more expensive to fix. Studies show that the increase in the cost of such repairs/replacements increases much faster than does the interest on such loans, so a 1 billion dollar job done currently when the costs of materials and labor are quite low may cost as much as 3 billion dollars in just a couple of years. So, we need to compare the current interest rates (quite low) with the cost increases coming, as wages and materials most definitely will rise in cost.

So, what do the Republicans actually want to do? They want to not borrow. They want to cut budgets well back below what actual tax receipts are. Most people like this “living within our means” talk, but is this actually what we do? The current federal budget has 5% of expenditures going to paying off our debt. In fourteen years, with nothing done, meaning deficit spending (at record levels) for another 14 years, as much as 15% of the federal budget will go to debt service. Let’s compare this with an average American family. For simplicity, say that a family’s after tax (federal and state) income is $50,000 per year. Does this family own a house? Probably yes. Let’s say the house costs $2000 per month, and if bought recently, 90+% of that is interest on the mortgage. So far, with a net income of $4170 per month, $1800 per month (90% of $2000) is going to service debt, which is 43% of the family’s budget. And we haven’t gotten to interest on car payments, credit cards, college student loans, and more.

Why are Republicans claiming we have this huge debt crisis? Take a guess. Politics maybe, hunh? Every time we have been in this situation before, austerity plans like the Republicans are demanding have sent us back into recession. It happened during the Great Depression, after World War II, and every other time it was tried. For a current example, see Britain; it is happening there right now.

Wall Street banks and “pro-business” economists state that if even the Republican plan for the federal budget getting us just to the end of the current cycle, in September, were implemented it could cost the economy 1.5-2% of growth. Currently economic growth is 2-3%. In other words, the Republican plan would completely stall the economy which is just beginning to recover from the worst recession since the 1930’s.

So, why are the Republicans doing this? The answer is apparently is the same no matter the subject of the question (Why are the Republicans doing anything?):  politics. The Republicans are against big government, except when it comes to planned parenthood, abortion, gay marriage, gay people serving opening in the military, etc. Republicans are for national defense, except when the Defense Department indicates there are weapons that don’t work and aren’t needed and then they say “you must take these, whether you want them or not.” Republicans are for free trade, except for all of the tax breaks that can be steered business’s way, giving them an advantage over foreign competitors (at one point the five most profitable corporations operating in the U.S. were oil companies, but the Republicans have insisted that they continue to receive mammoth tax breaks (the so-called “oil depletion allowance”).

The once proud Republican party has lowered itself to serving only itself and its corporate masters. Serving the country? Hardly.

Leave a Comment »

No comments yet.

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Create a free website or blog at

%d bloggers like this: